I guess because Arthur is suffering from Terminal illness and he has limited time and has a lot to do.. it's like he is on a countdown.

John's dead eye sounds of heartbeat because I feel because he had a more heartbreaking story.. The time he thought he had a normal life, his life ends.

What is your interpretation?

I’ve never fallen in love or immersed myself in a game like this.. even with all of the bugs, it was so perfect.. made me cry more times than I’d like to admit too. Arthur’s cutscene had me streaming tears man, I finished with a high honor, and I’m hoping to do a replay once I finish it all the way, with not only bad honor, but doing all the side shit

There was no reason for me to post this, it’s just such an amazing game man, felt like I had to tell the world

Ms Grimshaw came up to me at camp and stated that I wasn't contributing to the camp funds like I should and asked if I would start. I've been donating items and funds every time I return from a mission or trip, usually $25 - 50 per day. But then I realized that maybe she was referring to money we get from missions and robberies...where it shows the gang's share, ie the total take was $1,200 on a robbery and Micah and Arthur's share was $600 to split. That left $600 to the gang ($300 from each of us).

I assumed this automatically went to the gang and I didn't have to actually put it in the camp box, but then I noticed the camp balance hadn't increased much when I returned. So I put $300 into the box.

Is this the correct thing to do? Was I just not putting the gang's share into the box previously and that's why Grimshaw approached me?

I have not gone back to see if Micah put his share in.

Also, like others, I have caught Bill stealing from the camp box.

And it seems Arthur is putting in the lion's share of funds, according to the ledger.

I (Arthur) also bring in my hunting harvests to the camp instead of the butcher or the remote trader (Gus in online).

I’m currently working on getting stuff for the trapper. I need three perfect moose pelts. Fine enough. However, I’ve gone to every single moose spawn point I’ve seen and haven’t found a single one? Why must the game make them so nearly impossible to find?

I was double wielding a pair of M1899 pistols and something seemed off. They sounded different, one had a sharp crack and the other sounded duller, there was also a puff of black smoke from one of them. It took me longer than I’m proud to admit that I discovered it was one was fully clean and the other dirty as hell.

I love these little details, and I love there are more to find!